Contract award notice

Information

Published

Date of dispatch of this notice: 23/11/2022

External Reference: 2022-251669

TED Reference: 2022/S 229-661119

Contract award notice

Contract award notice

Results of the procurement procedure

Directive 2014/24/EU

Section I: Contracting authority

I.1)

Name and addresses

Credit Review Office
N/A
The Plaza
Dublin 3
East Point Business
IE
Contact person: Catherine Collins
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin
Internet address(es):
I.2)

Joint procurement

The contract is awarded by a central purchasing body
I.4)

Type of the contracting authority

Body governed by public law
I.5)

Main activity

Economic and financial affairs

Section II: Object

II.1)

Scope of the procurement

II.1.1)

Title

Multi Operator Framework Agreement for Credit Reviewers in 3 Lots
II.1.2)

Main CPV code

66110000  -  Banking services
II.1.3)

Type of contract

Services
II.1.4)

Short description

The Credit Review Office provides an independent appeals mechanism for SME and farm borrowers who have had their applications for credit, or credit restructuring, refused reduced or withdrawn. Credit Reviewers carry out a review of the banks decision, to assess if the business is viable/will be able to repay the facilities sought, reports to the Credit Committee in the Office and makes recommendations as to whether credit should be provided. Reviewers must be experienced in credit/lending.
II.1.6)

Information about lots

This contract is divided into lots: yes
II.1.7)

Total value of the procurement

Value excluding VAT:  520000.00  EUR
II.2)

Description

II.2.1)

Title

Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General
Lot No:  1
II.2.2)

Additional CPV code(s)

66113000  -  Credit granting services
66113100  -  Micro-credit granting services
66120000  -  Investment banking services and related services
II.2.3)

Place of performance

NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin
NUTS code:  IE0 -  IRELAND
II.2.4)

Description of the procurement

Tenderers were required to nominate resources for the role of Credit Reviewer. Each Credit Reviewer proposed must:
(i) be experienced in credit/lending, with either a banking, accountancy or other credit analyst background, and specialising in agriculture
(ii) have acted at senior management/ lending executive level
(iii) demonstrate creative deal making capability
(iv) have a working knowledge of accountancy concepts
(v) good working knowledge of Microsoft Office Word and Excel
II.2.5)

Award criteria

Criteria below
Quality criterion  -  Name:  Technical Merit of Human Resources Offered  /  Weighting:  50%
Quality criterion  -  Name:  Methodology for delivery of the service as evidenced via a Sample Case File  /  Weighting:  50%
Price  -  Weighting:  0
II.2.11)

Information about options

Options: no
II.2.13)

Information about European Union funds

The procurement is related to a project and/or programme financed by European Union funds: no
II.2.14)

Additional information

All information relating to tenders is published on
www.etenders.gov.ie
II.2)

Description

II.2.1)

Title

Lot 2 – Credit Reviewers – Agricultural Sector
Lot No:  2
II.2.2)

Additional CPV code(s)

66113000  -  Credit granting services
66113100  -  Micro-credit granting services
66120000  -  Investment banking services and related services
II.2.3)

Place of performance

NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin
II.2.4)

Description of the procurement

Tenderers were required to nominate resources for the role of Credit Reviewer. Each Credit Reviewer proposed must:
(i) be experienced in credit/lending, with either a banking, accountancy or other credit analyst background, and specialising in agriculture
(ii) have acted at senior management/ lending executive level
(iii) demonstrate creative deal making capability
(iv) have a working knowledge of accountancy concepts
(v) good working knowledge of Microsoft Office Word and Excel
II.2.5)

Award criteria

Criteria below
Quality criterion  -  Name:  Technical Merit of Human Resources Offered  /  Weighting:  50%
Quality criterion  -  Name:  Methodology for delivery of the service as evidenced via a Sample Case File  /  Weighting:  50%
Price  -  Weighting:  0
II.2.11)

Information about options

Options: no
II.2.13)

Information about European Union funds

The procurement is related to a project and/or programme financed by European Union funds: no
II.2.14)

Additional information

All information relating to tenders is published on
www.etenders.gov.ie
II.2)

Description

II.2.1)

Title

Lot 3 - Senior Reviewers - Representation/Mediation
Lot No:  3
II.2.2)

Additional CPV code(s)

66113000  -  Credit granting services
66113100  -  Micro-credit granting services
66120000  -  Investment banking services and related services
II.2.3)

Place of performance

NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin
II.2.4)

Description of the procurement

Minimum Requirements
i. Must be experienced in credit/lending, with either a banking, accountancy or other credit analyst background
ii. Must have acted at senior management level
iii. Must demonstrate creative deal making capability
iv. Must have a working knowledge of accountancy concepts
v. Must be able to work independently and as part of a team
vi. Must have a good working knowledge of Microsoft Office Word and Excel products in addition to Adobe
II.2.5)

Award criteria

Criteria below
Quality criterion  -  Name:  Technical Merit of Human Resources Offered  /  Weighting:  50%
Quality criterion  -  Name:  Methodology for delivery of the service as evidenced via a Sample Case File  /  Weighting:  50%
Price  -  Weighting:  0
II.2.11)

Information about options

Options: no
II.2.13)

Information about European Union funds

The procurement is related to a project and/or programme financed by European Union funds: no
II.2.14)

Additional information

All information relating to tenders is published on
www.etenders.gov.ie

Section IV: Procedure

IV.1)

Description

IV.1.1)

Type of procedure

Open procedure
IV.1.3)

Information about a framework agreement or a dynamic purchasing system

The procurement involves the establishment of a framework agreement
IV.1.8)

Information about the Government Procurement Agreement (GPA)

The procurement is covered by the Government Procurement Agreement : yes
IV.2)

Administrative information

IV.2.1)

Previous publication concerning this procedure

Notice number in the OJ S: 2022/S 105-293744

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 1

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Admor Business Solutions
1234
Unit 207 Moat House, 54 Bloomfield Avenue
Belfast
Antrim
UK
Telephone: +44 2890773008
NUTS code:  UKN0 -  Northern Ireland

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 2

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

AJS Financial Advice Ltd
IE 9709295D
8 Farmleigh Park, Blackrock.
Dublin
Dublin
IE
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 3

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Bobby Connolly & Associates
480486
1 Chantiere Gate,
Portlaoise
Laois
IE
Telephone: +353 868147780
NUTS code:  IE06 -  Eastern and Midland
Internet address: http://N/A

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 4

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Brendan Gaynor
Not registered
Brinny House
Innishannon
T12VPW5/Cork
IE
NUTS code:  IE052 -  South-East
Internet address: http://NA

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 5

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Brian McAuliffe
7650242N
86 Meadowvale, Raheen
Limerick
V94RRN4
IE
NUTS code:  IE051 -  Mid-West
Internet address: http://N/A

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 6

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Creditknowledge Ltd
2927692t
Castleknock
Dublin
Dublin
IE
Telephone: +353 862678240
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 7

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

DKFinancial Solutions
492140B
Golf Links Road,Bettystown
Meath
Meath
IE
Telephone: +353 862576706
NUTS code:  IE062 -  Mid-East

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 8

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

First Choice Financial Services Limited
6350271O
12th Floor, Riverpoint Building, Lower Mallow St
Limerick
Limerick
IE
Telephone: +353 860220922
Fax: +353 61317263
NUTS code:  IE051 -  Mid-West

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 9

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Kevin McGarry
3386032U
31 MONSWOOD
Clarkes Hill Rochestown
T12WDY9
IE
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin
Internet address: http://n/a

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 10

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Lorcan Power t/a Financial Solutions
5184376v
1 Willsbrook Road, Esker Woods,
Lucan
Dublin
IE
Telephone: +353 877374903
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 11

Lot No: 1

Title: Lot 1 – Credit Reviewers – General

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  12
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  12
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Morphyl Consulting Limited
370740TH
Carraig Airt, Dublin Road
Kilkenny
R95 R6PD
IE
Telephone: +353 868183754
NUTS code:  IE062 -  Mid-East

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  320000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 12

Lot No: 2

Title: Lot 2 – Credit Reviewers – Agricultural Sector

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  5
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  5
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Brian McAuliffe
7650242N
86 Meadowvale, Raheen
Limerick
V94RRN4
IE
NUTS code:  IE051 -  Mid-West
Internet address: http://N/A

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 13

Lot No: 2

Title: Lot 2 – Credit Reviewers – Agricultural Sector

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  5
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  5
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Creditknowledge Ltd
2927692t
Castleknock
Dublin
Dublin
IE
Telephone: +353 862678240
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 14

Lot No: 2

Title: Lot 2 – Credit Reviewers – Agricultural Sector

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  5
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  5
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Hugh O'Callaghan
n/a
Desert, Clonakilty,
Cork
Cork
IE
Telephone: +353 238821857
NUTS code:  IE052 -  South-East
Internet address: http://n/a

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 15

Lot No: 2

Title: Lot 2 – Credit Reviewers – Agricultural Sector

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  5
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  5
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Stafford Farm Finance
421680
Roselawn, Hurdlestown ,
kells
Meath
IE
Telephone: +353 0469027082
NUTS code:  IE062 -  Mid-East

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 16

Lot No: 3

Title: Lot 3 - Senior Reviewers - Representation/Mediation

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  6
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  6
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

Admor Business Solutions
1234
Unit 207 Moat House, 54 Bloomfield Avenue
Belfast
Antrim
UK
Telephone: +44 2890773008
NUTS code:  UKN06 -  Belfast

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 17

Lot No: 3

Title: Lot 3 - Senior Reviewers - Representation/Mediation

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  6
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  6
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

AJS Financial Advice Ltd
IE 9709295D
8 Farmleigh Park, Blackrock.
Dublin
Dublin
IE
NUTS code:  IE061 -  Dublin

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section V: Award of contract

Contract No: 18

Lot No: 3

Title: Lot 3 - Senior Reviewers - Representation/Mediation

A contract/lot is awarded: yes
V.2)

Award of contract

V.2.1)

Date of conclusion of the contract

26/09/2022
V.2.2)

Information about tenders

Number of tenders received:  6
Number of tenders received by electronic means:  6
The contract has been awarded to a group of economic operators :  no
V.2.3)

Name and address of the contractor

First Choice Financial Services Limited
6350271O
12th Floor, Riverpoint Building, Lower Mallow St
Limerick
Limerick
IE
Telephone: +353 860220922
Fax: +353 61317263
NUTS code:  IE051 -  Mid-West

The contractor is an SME : yes
V.2.4)

Information on value of the contract/lot (excluding VAT)

Total value of the contract/lot:  100000.00  EUR

Section VI: Complementary information

VI.3)

Additional information

1) Interested parties must register their interest on the eTenders web site (www.etenders.gov.ie) in order to be included on the mailing list for clarifications. All information relating to attachments, including clarifications and changes, will be published on the Irish Government Procurement Opportunities Portal (www.etenders.gov.ie) only. Registration is free of charge. The contracting authority will not accept responsibility for information relayed (or not relayed) via third parties.
2) Suppliers must register their interest on the eTenders web site (www.etenders.gov.ie) in order to be included on the mailing list for clarifications and to respond electronically to the competition.
3) Suppliers should note the following when making their submission:
• There is a maximum upload limit of 2GB per file. Documents larger than this should be divided into smaller files prior to upload.
• In order to submit a document to the electronic postbox, please note that you must click “Submit Response”. After submitting a response, the response may be modified and re-submitted as many times as may be necessary until the RFT deadline has expired. Suppliers should be aware that the “Submit Response” button will be disabled automatically upon expiration of the response deadline.
• Suppliers must ensure that they give themselves sufficient time to upload & submit all required documentation before the submission deadline. Suppliers should consider the fact that upload speeds vary.
• If you experience difficulty when uploading documents, please contact eTenders Support Desk for technical assistance. Email etenders@eusupply.com or Telephone: 353(0)21 2439277 (09:00am – 17:30pm GMT). All queries must be submitted through the messaging facility on www.etenders.gov.ie.
4) All queries regarding this tender requirement or process must be submitted through the Irish Government Procurement Opportunities Portal www.etenders.gov.ie as a specific question. Responses will be circulated to those tenderers that have registered an interest in this notice on www.etenders.gov.ie The details of the person making a query will not be disclosed when circulating the response
5) This is the sole call for competition for this contract/framework.
6) The contracting authority will not be responsible for any costs, charges or expenses incurred by candidates or tenderers.
7) Contract award will be subject to the approval of the competent authorities.
8) It will be a condition of award that the successful tenderer is and remains tax compliant.
9) At its absolute discretion, the contracting authority may elect to terminate this procurement process, the framework agreement or any contract awarded under the framework agreement at any time.
10) Please note in relation to all documents, that where reference is made to a particular standard, make, source, process, trademark, type, or patent, that this is not to be regarded as a de facto requirement. In all such cases it should be understood that such indications are to be treated strictly and solely for reference purposes only, to which the words "or equivalent" will always be appended.
11) Without prejudice to the principle of equal treatment, the contracting authority is not obliged to engage in a
clarification process in respect of the procurement documents with missing or incomplete information. Therefore, respondents are advised to ensure that they return completed documentation in order to avoid the risk of elimination from the competition.
VI.4)

Procedures for review

VI.4.1)

Review body

High Court
Four Courts
Dublin 7
IE
Telephone: +353 18886000
Internet address: www.courts.ie