Award of a contract without prior publication of a call for competition in the Official Journal of the European Union in the cases listed below
- The procurement falls outside the scope of application of the directive
Explanation
The award of the contract specified in this notice falls outside the scope of the application of Directive 2014/24/EU by relying upon the provisions of Article 36 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union.
The COVID-19 global pandemic presented (and continues to present) an extraordinary challenge to the HSE. The HSE required at short notice the provision of laboratory facilities for testing COVID-19 samples provided by the National Virus Reference Laboratory capable of providing over 15,000 tests.
Worldwide testing capacity was extremely limited as Member States acquired the totality of domestic capacity. In the absence of national testing capacity, Ireland was at serious risk of risk to human life as a consequence of its inability to test suspected COVID-19 patients. As the EU Commission stated in a Communication (COM (2020) 112 final) on 13 March 2020,
“It is the primary responsibility of EU Member States to take the appropriate health measures in the context of the current crisis. It is crucial that the primary objective of protection of health and human life is pursued by all national measures in compliance with EU rules. The internal market rules support Member States in this respect by ensuring efficiency, synergies and European solidarity.”
Acknowledging that responsibility, Ireland must be capable of end-to-end laboratory testing and diagnostic services within its national boundaries. In the absence of this testing capacity, Ireland’s exposure to a future crisis, (or an extreme escalation in the current crisis) poses unacceptable risk.
The ECJ has ruled in the past that quantitative restrictions may be allowed to protect public health which may take precedence over the free movement of goods but such restrictions must be proportionate (i.e. there must be no alternative means of protecting public health other than the quantitative restriction proposed). The HSE viewed the requirement to provide such laboratory capacity as appropriate, necessary and proportionate to achieve the objective of protecting human life by ensuring adequate testing capacity.
The HSE’s contract with Enfer provides testing capacity until May 2021 (with a possible extension). The HSE intends to award future contracts for COVID-19 laboratory testing services via a tender process and reserves the right to rely upon the provisions of Article 36 in any future process. The HSE also believes that the provisions of Article 32(2)(2)(c) of the Directive 2012/24/EU apply and reserves the right to rely upon Article 32(2)(2)(c) at a later date.
The procurement is covered by the Government Procurement Agreement
: yes